Mon-Fri 9-8 | Sat-Sun 9-5

How to Stop Beating Yourself Up: 4 Steps to Tame Your Inner Critic

Dr. Dana McNeil

To stop beating yourself up, start by noticing when your inner critic is talking, then separate that voice from who you are, talk back to it with facts and kindness, and build a new, supportive inner voice that speaks to you the way you’d speak to a good friend. It won’t happen overnight; self-criticism is a habit, and new habits take practice. If the critic is loud enough to affect your mood, sleep or relationships, one-on-one mental health therapy can help.

What Does Beating Yourself Up Mean?

Beating yourself up means harshly criticizing yourself, often over and over, for mistakes, flaws or things you think you should have done differently. It usually comes from an inner critic: the voice in your head that judges you, puts you down and compares you to others. It tells you you’re not good enough or smart enough, and it says things you would never dream of saying to another person.

There’s a difference between healthy reflection and beating yourself up. Reflection asks, “What can I learn from this?” and then moves on. Beating yourself up replays the same moment, attacks your character (“I’m such an idiot”) rather than the behavior, and leaves you feeling worse without helping you do better.

Why Do You Beat Yourself Up?

You weren’t born with an inner critic; you picked it up along the way. Common sources include:

  • Childhood messages. Critical, demanding or unpredictable caregivers can leave you repeating their voice in your own head.
  • Perfectionism. When anything less than perfect feels like failure, ordinary mistakes become proof that you’re not good enough.
  • A belief that criticism keeps you in line. Many people fear that if they stop being hard on themselves, they’ll become lazy or careless.
  • Anxiety and depression. Both can make negative thoughts about yourself louder and more convincing.
  • Past trauma or shame. Painful experiences can leave a lasting sense that something is wrong with you.

How Does Beating Yourself Up Affect You?

You might think the inner critic, while annoying, is relatively harmless. It isn’t. Constant self-criticism limits you and keeps you from living the life you want. It drains motivation rather than building it, makes you more afraid of trying new things and wears down your self-esteem. Left unchecked, it can contribute to anxiety and depression.

It affects relationships too. When you’re hard on yourself, you may become defensive with your partner, struggle to accept compliments or love, or assume others see you as harshly as you see yourself.

What Are the 4 Steps to Stop Beating Yourself Up?

1. Give It Attention

To gain control over your inner critic, you first have to notice it. Most of our thinking is automatic; we barely register a critical thought before it has passed. Pay attention to your thoughts, all of them. Emotional clues that the critic is at work include doubt, guilt, shame and feeling worthless.

2. Separate Yourself From Your Inner Critic

Your inner critic hopes you’ll think its thoughts are your own. One way to separate yourself is to give the critic a name. Have fun with it: you could call it anything from “Todd” to “Ms. Annoying Loudmouth.” What matters is learning that the critic is a voice you have, not who you are.

3. Talk Back

To take away the critic’s power, answer it. When you notice it, name it (“There’s Todd again”), check its claims against the facts and tell it you’re choosing to be kind to yourself instead. Self-compassion to an inner critic is like garlic to a vampire.

4. Create a New Inner Voice

Build a stronger, more supportive voice, one that is on your side. Start noticing the good things about yourself: your strengths, your efforts and the times you handled something well. It will feel awkward at first to see yourself in a positive light, but the more you practice, the easier it gets.

What Should You Say to Yourself Instead of Beating Yourself Up?

Try talking to yourself the way you would talk to a friend in the same situation. Psychologist Kristin Neff describes self-compassion as being warm and understanding toward yourself when you struggle, remembering that everyone makes mistakes, and acknowledging your feelings without exaggerating them. In practice, that might sound like:

  • Instead of “I’m so stupid,” try: “I made a mistake. Everyone does. What can I learn from it?”
  • Instead of “I always mess things up,” try: “This one didn’t go well. Plenty of things have.”
  • Instead of “I should be further along by now,” try: “I’m doing the best I can with what I have right now.”
  • Instead of “Nobody would want to be with me,” try: “I’m feeling insecure right now, and that feeling will pass.”

Over time, these new responses become more automatic. For more ways to build a kinder relationship with yourself, read our tips on raising your self-esteem.

When Should You Talk to a Therapist About Beating Yourself Up?

Some people’s inner critic is stronger than others. Consider talking to a therapist if:

  • Self-criticism is constant and you can’t turn it down on your own.
  • It’s affecting your sleep, work, mood or relationships.
  • You feel persistent shame, hopelessness or worthlessness.
  • It’s linked to past trauma, anxiety or depression.

A therapist can be the ally in your corner, an impartial third party who can see you for who you really are and help you build a kinder inner voice. If your thoughts ever turn to hurting yourself, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline right away.

If you or a loved one could use help with your inner critic, call The Relationship Place at (619) 535-8890. I would be happy to talk with you about how I may be able to help.

Scroll to Top